Andre Onana made two costly errors in the 3-3 draw with Galatasaray which could cost Manchester United a place in the Champions League knockout stages.
Onana was rooted to the spot when Hakim Ziyech smashed a direct free-kick through his wall after Alejandro Garnacho and Bruno Fernandes had carved a commanding first-half lead.
Scott McTominay restored a two-goal advantage after the break but Onana was at fault again when he failed to hold a tame shot from another Ziyech direct free-kick – before a Kerem Akturkoglu stunner ensured the spoils were shared.
United’s new stopper – signed from Inter Milan for £47.2m to replace long-standing No 1 David De Gea in the summer – also committed a howler at Bayern Munich in September and made a dreadful pass which resulted in Casemiro seeing red against Galatasaray at Old Trafford a fortnight later – before falling to ground early as Mauro Icardi netted the late winner.
The Cameroon international helped guide Inter Milan to a Champions League final before his big-money move to Old Trafford but still has a statistical history of underperforming on the European stage – having made seven errors leading to goals in the competition since 2018/19 – more than any other stopper.
Onana has made four mistakes leading to shots during this European campaign alone, according to Opta’s official definition of errors – more than any other ‘keeper. Of those, two have resulted in goals – no stopper has shipped more.
According to expected goals (xG), United’s No 1 should have conceded 11.59 goals but has shipped 14 – which is 2.41 goals more than expected. Only Antwerp goalkeeper Jean Butez has a worse ratio (-3.59), and his side have suffered five straight defeats, shipped 15 goals and been eliminated from the competition.
Onana’s tally of 2.41 unnecessary goals conceded equates to shipping 0.48 goals more than expected per 90 minutes – only Butez (-0.90) and Inter Milan stopper Emil Audero (-0.79) have worse ratios, and the latter has played only one game.
But the mystery lies in the Cameroonian’s polarised form between haphazard Champions League and solid Premier League performances. Domestically, question marks were raised early in the season after an untidy penalty shout against Wolves but, since then, Onana has impressed between the sticks.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
Melissa Reddy and Samuel Luckhurst reflect on Manchester United’s thrilling 3-3 draw at Galatasaray in the Champions League
United have ceded more chances than they did last season, meaning Onana has been forced into making nearly four saves per game on average – only three ‘keepers have averaged more. He is also faultless – not even making one single mistake leading to a shot.
Additionally, xG suggests Onana has actually prevented 0.28 goals per 90 minutes – only Thomas Kaminski and Neto have better ratios in the division this term.
Compare that with the Champions League, where Ziyech’s first free-kick goal registered a meagre five-per-cent probability of being scored, and his second merely four per cent. The polarised form across competitions appears to have seriously dented United’s hopes of qualifying for the knockout stages.
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
The Football Show team discuss whether Manchester United boss Erik ten Hag might look to replace Andre Onana after more mistakes in their Champions League match against Galatasaray
Speaking to TNT Sports after the game, Erik ten Hag said: “We are not defending well enough, we are leading 3-1 and you can’t afford such mistakes because it makes a difference. These mistakes can’t happen. In the Champions League you will get punished and we have to learn from that.”
Onana is under the spotlight once again and Ten Hag will be hoping his pass-master ‘keeper will snuff out table-topping mistakes on Europe’s grand stage ahead of their blockbuster and fate-defining clash with Bayern at Old Trafford in two weeks’ time.
United must now beat Bayern on the final matchday and hope Galatasaray draw at Copenhagen to qualify for the knockout phase.
